A Taste of St. Augustine

St. Augustine is home to an enticing variety of places to dine, from historic restaurants and fresh local seafood to creative cuisine and romantic dinner spots. Many of our favorite restaurants are within an easy walk of the Penny Farthing Inn, while others are just a short drive away.

Here are a few of the places we recommend for lunch or dinner during your stay.

Within Walking Distance

of Penny Farthing Inn

Catch 27 is a favorite for fresh local seafood, seasonal ingredients and creative dishes in a charming historic district setting. The inviting atmosphere makes it a wonderful choice for a relaxed lunch or a special dinner.

Collage is perfect for a romantic evening or special occasion. It offers an intimate setting and beautifully prepared seafood, steaks and other creative dishes. Its cozy atmosphere and extensive wine selection make it a favorite for a memorable dinner.

Columbia Restaurant, a St. Augustine tradition, has been serving Spanish and Cuban cuisine in the historic district for generations. Enjoy traditional dishes, the famous 1905 Salad and the beautiful atmosphere of this historic restaurant.

Harry’s Seafood, Bar & Grille brings New Orleans inspired flavors to St. Augustine, with seafood, Cajun and Creole favorites served in a lively historic setting. Its beautiful courtyard and live music make it a particularly fun choice for an evening out.

Café Alcazar, located inside the historic Lightner Museum (pictured), offers a truly memorable setting for lunch. Enjoy a relaxed meal in the former swimming pool of Henry Flagler’s Alcazar Hotel, surrounded by the history and architecture of old St. Augustine.

Ice Plant Bar, located in a beautifully restored historic building, combines creative cocktails with locally inspired food in a distinctive setting. It is a lively choice for dinner, drinks or an evening out in the historic district.

Other Nearby Favorites

Worth the Short Drive

Llama offers an intimate dining experience centered around creative Peruvian cuisine and beautifully presented dishes. For guests looking to try something a little different, this is a wonderful choice for a special dinner.

St. Augustine Fish Camp offers a relaxed waterfront setting where you’ll enjoy fresh seafood and coastal favorites. With river views and a casual atmosphere, it is a great choice when you want to enjoy a little of the coastal character of St. Augustine.

The Floridian puts a creative spin on Southern cooking, with locally sourced ingredients, Florida seafood and plenty of vegetarian and gluten free choices. It is a relaxed option for guests who enjoy thoughtful food in a casual setting.

Raintree, housed in a charming historic setting, offers a more traditional fine dining experience with steaks, seafood and an extensive wine selection. It is a lovely choice for a quiet dinner or special celebration.

More Local Favorites

These are just a few of the restaurants we enjoy recommending to our guests. Our Touch Stay digital guest guide includes additional local dining favorites and recommendations, and we are always happy to help you find a restaurant that suits your plans.